Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

A tall, frosty glass of this Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream is basically Christmas in milkshake form. It’s thick, creamy, and full of that cozy eggnog flavor you wait for all year, all swirled together with rich vanilla ice cream and a cloud of whipped cream on top.

Whether you’re making a quick holiday dessert for guests, a fun Christmas Eve treat for the kids (just skip the alcohol), or a festive date-night drink, this milkshake delivers big flavor with almost zero effort. You only need a few simple ingredients and a blender, and dessert is ready in minutes.

---

Why You’ll Love This Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream

This eggnog milkshake has that classic holiday flavor, but it’s much lighter and silkier than sipping eggnog straight from the carton. Blending the eggnog with vanilla ice cream gives you a luscious texture that feels like a cross between a float and a classic diner shake.

It’s also incredibly customizable. Make it kid‑friendly by keeping it alcohol‑free, or turn it into a grown‑up dessert with a splash of rum or bourbon. Top each glass with whipped cream, nutmeg, and maybe a drizzle of caramel and you’ve got a party‑ready treat in under 5 minutes.

---

What Kind of Vanilla Ice Cream Works Best for an Eggnog Milkshake?

For the creamiest, dreamiest texture, use a full‑fat, good‑quality vanilla ice cream. “French vanilla” or “vanilla bean” ice cream adds extra richness and tiny flecks of vanilla that look beautiful in the glass. If you prefer a slightly lighter shake, you can use a light vanilla ice cream or even a vanilla frozen yogurt, but the milkshake will be a bit thinner.

If you’re serving a crowd, you can even mix and match—use classic vanilla for the base and add a scoop of cinnamon or caramel ice cream to one or two glasses for a fun twist. Just keep the basic ratio of eggnog to ice cream the same so the milkshake stays thick and spoonable.

---

Ingredients for the Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream

To make this holiday milkshake, you only need a short list of ingredients, but each one makes a big difference in flavor and texture. Using chilled ingredients keeps the shake thick and frosty, while warm spices and toppings bring all the cozy holiday vibes.

• 2 cups chilled eggnog
• 2 cups vanilla ice cream, slightly softened (about 4 large scoops)
• 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg, plus extra for sprinkling on top
• 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (optional, for extra vanilla flavor)
• 2 tablespoons rum or bourbon, or 1 teaspoon rum extract (optional, for an adults‑only version)
• Whipped cream, for topping
• Caramel sauce or cinnamon sugar, for garnish (optional)

---

How To Make the Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream

This milkshake comes together in just a few simple steps. For the best texture, work quickly so everything stays nice and cold.

Step 1: Chill the Glasses

Place your serving glasses in the freezer for 10–15 minutes while you gather and measure the ingredients. Chilled glasses help the milkshake stay thick and frosty longer.

Step 2: Build the Milkshake Base

Add the chilled eggnog, vanilla ice cream, ground nutmeg, and vanilla extract (if using) to a blender. If you’re making an adults‑only version, add the rum, bourbon, or rum extract at this stage.

Step 3: Blend Until Creamy

Blend on medium‑high speed until the mixture is smooth, thick, and creamy. If the milkshake seems too thick to pour, blend in a splash more eggnog. If it’s too thin for your liking, add another small scoop of ice cream and blend again.

Step 4: Taste and Adjust

Give the milkshake a quick taste. Add a pinch more nutmeg for extra spice, a few drops more vanilla for deeper flavor, or a bit more eggnog if you’d like a looser consistency. Blend briefly to combine.

Step 5: Garnish and Serve

Remove the chilled glasses from the freezer and divide the eggnog milkshake between them. Top generously with whipped cream, then finish with a sprinkle of ground nutmeg and a drizzle of caramel sauce if you like. Add a festive straw and serve immediately while perfectly cold.

---

How to Serve and Store This Eggnog Milkshake (and How Many It Feeds)

This Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream is best enjoyed right away while it’s thick and frosty. The recipe makes about 2 large servings or 3 smaller ones, depending on the size of your glasses.

For a party, you can easily double or triple the recipe and serve the milkshakes in smaller glasses or mini dessert cups so everyone gets a taste. Add a little sprinkle station with nutmeg, cinnamon sugar, and caramel so guests can customize their toppings.

If you have leftover milkshake (lucky you!), you can store it in an airtight container in the freezer for up to 1 month. Let it sit at room temperature for 10–15 minutes, then stir or blend again to revive the texture before serving. It’s not quite the same as fresh, but it still tastes like a holiday treat.

---

What to Serve With Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream

Classic Holiday Cookies

Pair this milkshake with your favorite Christmas cookies—sugar cookies, butter cookies, or snickerdoodles all work beautifully. The crisp, buttery cookies contrast with the creamy shake for the perfect holiday dessert combo.

Warm Dessert Bars or Cake

A square of warm blondies, brownies, or a slice of spiced cake is amazing alongside this cold shake. The hot‑and‑cold contrast feels extra indulgent and is perfect for cozy nights in.

Savory Party Snacks

If you’re serving these eggnog milkshakes at a holiday party, balance out the sweetness with salty snacks like cheese boards, pretzels, or savory appetizers. The contrast keeps your guests from hitting a sugar overload too quickly.

Festive Brunch Spread

This milkshake doubles as a decadent brunch drink. Serve it alongside pancakes, waffles, or an egg‑based dish for a special holiday breakfast or brunch.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Make This Eggnog Milkshake Without Alcohol?

Absolutely. This recipe is just as delicious without any alcohol, so it’s perfect for kids or anyone who prefers a non‑alcoholic dessert. Simply leave out the rum or bourbon and, if you still want that hint of classic flavor, add a teaspoon of rum extract instead. You’ll still get all the rich eggnog taste with none of the booze.

How Do I Make the Milkshake Thicker or Thinner?

To make a thicker milkshake, add an extra scoop of vanilla ice cream and blend briefly until smooth. For a thinner, more sippable milkshake, blend in more eggnog a little at a time until you reach your ideal consistency. Remember that the shake will thicken slightly as it stands, so aim for just a bit thinner than your perfect texture if you’re serving it right away.

Can I Use Homemade Eggnog?

Yes, homemade eggnog works wonderfully in this recipe and can make the milkshake taste even more special. If your homemade eggnog is very sweet or very rich, you might want to use a slightly lighter vanilla ice cream to keep the shake from becoming too heavy. You can also balance the sweetness by serving it alongside something a bit less sweet, like a slice of pumpkin bread.

What Other Holiday Desserts Pair Well With This Milkshake?

This milkshake pairs beautifully with cozy, spiced desserts. Try it with a slice of gingerbread cake or a plate of buttery shortbread cookies. If you’re setting up a dessert table, consider adding a fruity option like a berry tart or cobbler to balance the richness of the eggnog.

Can I Serve This Milkshake as Part of a Holiday Drinks Bar?

Definitely. Set up a festive drink station with this eggnog milkshake as the star, and offer a few contrasting options like hot chocolate, coffee, or a chilled iced matcha latte. Add fun toppings—whipped cream, chocolate shavings, crushed candy canes, caramel drizzle—so everyone can garnish their glass just the way they like it.

---

Save This Pin For Later

📌 Save this Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream to your holiday dessert or drinks board on Pinterest so you can come back to it any time.

And let me know in the comments how yours turned out. Did you spike it with rum or keep it kid‑friendly? Did you go extra on the whipped cream or add caramel drizzle on top?

I love hearing how others make these recipes their own. Questions are welcome too—let’s help each other mix, blend, and celebrate smarter.

---

Conclusion

This Best Ever Eggnog Milkshake With Vanilla Ice Cream is one of those easy holiday treats that feels instantly festive, even on a busy weeknight. With just a blender and a few simple ingredients, you can serve a dessert that tastes like it came from a cozy café—complete with whipped cream, nutmeg, and all the holiday charm.

Keep this recipe in your back pocket for Christmas parties, New Year’s Eve, or any chilly evening when you’re craving something sweet and nostalgic. And if you’re looking for even more fun drinks and desserts to round out your menu, you can find plenty of inspiration over on Meals We Share.

---

Print

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?